WikiIndex:Open proxy events - 2014-03
Table of contents |
Originally created by User:Abd as a sub-page from his own user page, this began as a list of IP addresses involved in harassment of Leucosticte here on WikiIndex. Below, there are additional IPs that vandalize. It turns out, so far, that all involved IPs in harassment are using open proxies. No legitimate edits have been noticed in this period from open proxies. There is a possible obvious recommendation.
The time period begins with 7 March 2014, the appearance of Sophie Wilder here, going after Leucosticte. Sophie Wilder, presumably the same user, is a moderator on RationalWiki. ('Sysop' on RationalWiki means almost nothing. I am a sysop on RationalWiki. At least today I am! Moderators there are elected and have advanced privileges.
For each IP, I searched for global blocks on the Wikimedia Meta-Wiki at meta.Wikimedia.org. If the IP showed as globally blocked, I linked to the global block display for it. no means not blocked globally. Most Meta blocks for open proxies are range blocks.
Then, if the IP was not globally blocked on Meta, I searched for the IP with Google.
See Wikipedia WikiProject on identifying open proxies. I am not going to those lengths. I'm just looking for obvious indications by Googling the address. If a search showed accusations of open proxy, that is shown by 'Google'. If not, by 'no Google evidence'. I did not search for addresses shown as blocked open proxies by Meta.
IP harassment
| IP address | WikiIndex block status |
WMF global block |
notes / comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| 194.132.32.42 | short-term block | nb | |
| 5.199.130.188 | 1 contrib, harassing, short-term block | no | (same user as above, threatens TOR) see open proxy |
| 77.244.254.227 | short-term block | open proxy | |
| 37.221.162.226 | 4 contribs, harassing, blocked | really nasty evil harassment; open proxy | |
| 77.95.231.11 | 1 contrib, harassing, short-term block | no | evil harassment; Google |
| 70.39.66.59 | 3 contribs, short-term block | no | |
| 93.184.66.227 | 1 contrib, short-term block | open proxy | |
| 89.207.132.76 | 1 contrib, harassing, not blocked | no | |
| 109.163.234.2 | short-term block | open proxy | |
| 62.210.129.149 | short-term block | open proxy | |
| 212.232.24.57 | short-term block | no | |
| 95.130.9.190 | blocked | open proxy | |
| 77.247.181.164 | not blocked | no | harassing, active, connected with other harassing IPs, see [1], Google |
| 171.25.193.20 | contributions possibly positive | open proxy | |
| 81.89.96.89 | 1 contrib, blocked | open proxy | |
| 141.138.141.208 | 1 contrib, harassment, not blocked | no | |
| 178.217.187.39 | 1 contrib, blocked | no | |
| 77.109.141.138 | 2 contribs, harassing, not blocked | no | |
| 82.94.251.227 | blocked | no | |
| 37.221.171.236 | blocked | open proxy | |
| 198.96.155.3 | blocked (one old edit from this IP) | open proxy | |
| 109.163.234.7 | harassment, not blocked | note same range as above, x.x.x.2 open proxy threatens ddos attacks | |
| 192.99.8.96 | harassment, not blocked | new attack page creation, spambot, likely open proxy | |
| 212.83.187.52 | harassment, not blocked | no | |
| 95.211.98.166 | harassment, not blocked | open proxy | |
| 81.169.151.138 | harassment, not blocked | no | |
| 5.104.224.5 | harassment, not blocked | no | |
| 77.109.141.138 | no | ||
| 85.10.211.53 | open proxy This IP did not go after Leucosticte or site admin, but after a new user, apparently the same as .241 listed above with 'many positive contributions', who is now doing a great deal of positive editing from a registered account. If the IP is connected with the attack on Leucosticte, this would be an attempt to harass a WikiIndex user as retaliation for the site allowing Leucosticte to edit. | ||
| 185.17.93.142 | no | ||
| 77.247.181.164 | no |
Fascinating how some who call others "cowards" are using anonymizing techniques, starting with IP editing, then anonymizing the IP, while harassing registered users who are using — or readily connected with real names. Cowards, full of hatred, terrorists.
Related
That these are related does not indicate specific connection. While Sophie Wilder was radically uncivil, that is merely the custom at RationalWiki. I have seen no evidence that the IP connection with Sophie Wilder was anything more than an offer of assistance from them to her. I know of no history of Sophie Wilder using open proxies.
- 76.28.31.199 was me (Abd).
- 213.93.202.241 many positive contributions; no, no Google evidence.
Disclosure of Abd's position
Leucosticte is a user who can generate controversy. He supports highly unpopular causes However, he also absolutely responds to community restraint, usually, if it is civil and rational. He may argue endlessly, given the opportunity, but he is also capable of backing off and simply contributing within site purpose.
My initial work here was to interdict the vandalism, the attack on Leucosticte, which was pure bullying and what I called "terrorism"; that is, an attempt to attain ends deemed, by the terrorists, to be so important as to allow massive collateral damage, and whatever extreme action is considered, by them, as necessary. The enemies of Leucosticte have done much worse than what has been seen here. Threats of physical violence have been made, and threats have extended to others seen as defending him; i.e., to Abd. Here, there has merely been gross incivility, vandalism, and revert warring.
The flood of IP vandalism having abated, for the moment, I then turned to the other side of this. Leucosticte has been adding provocative content here. I have begun to tag some of this for deletion. One might, in Leucosticte's defense, notice that he does not revert war over a deletion tag. Rather, he argues on the attached talk page. He is an experienced wiki user, and only revert warred, in the last week, with blatant vandals. (As did I).
(I was blocked on a WMF wiki by a somewhat dizzy admin for revert warring with a blocked editor, editing IP, who was repeatedly adding 'outing' information. And I'd do it again. Basically, being blocked causes no pain. The real problem there was administrative inattention, a common problem on wikis. The administrator who blamed me for disturbing his nap. No, I did, however, probably cause him to wake up a little sooner. Which was the point. Otherwise there would have been one or two edits buried in the noise.)
(There is a policy here against revert warring. Such policies need exceptions. The policy assumes good faith editing.) --Abd (talk) 21:53, 12 March 2014 (UTC)
Ancient history
Looking back a bit further:
- 92.28.210.211 edited 16:59, 3 March 2014, identifying as Sophie. The edit was non-disruptive, to RationalWikiWiki. The last editor before her was Leucosticte. The IP is blocked here, now, though that IP was not used to make any disruptive edits. This is not an open proxy, apparently. Sophie is really Sophie.
- User:Sophie Wilder was created here 00:08, 4 March 2014.
- The first edit of the registered Sophie Wilder was 09:16, 4 March 2014, a non-disruptive edit to Talk:RationalWiki (en). (It looks from her user registration declaration that she may have edited here before. Name not given.)
- However, the next edit was 09:19, 4 March 2014, recognizing Leucosticte and attacking him. She pretends surprise at his presence. From the speed with which she found his work, it seems likely that she came here, knowing what she would find.
- The offer of assistance from massive TOR editing came March 5 on her talk page. She did not reject or discourage the offer. Looking back, there was IP editing harassing Leucosticte — or at least calling attention to his politics — for quite some time.
| IP address | WikiIndex block status |
WMF global block |
notes / comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| 77.247.181.162 | no | 3 March 2014 possible vandalism, unclear; Google | |
| 62.210.129.149 | blocked (presumably from later activity) | listed above as open proxy, was active 1 March 2014 with a largely harmless edit | |
| 77.109.141.138 | listed above as open proxy, was also active 27 February 2014 with an apparently harmless edit; however, the change appears to be incorrect, subtle vandalism, perhaps | ||
| 171.25.193.20 | listed above as open proxy, was active 26 February 2014 | ||
| 77.247.181.164 | no | active 25 February 2014, created Category:Pedophilia and applied it to Nathan Larson wikis; Google; intentions became clear with [2] | |
| 185.12.7.248 | no | ||
| 198.180.167.4 | no | ||
| 173.254.216.69 | open proxy | ||
| 94.102.49.175 | no | ||
| 194.132.32.42 | no | ||
| 94.242.205.2 | 23 February 2014 open proxy | ||
| 68.57.45.104 | no | is Nathan Larson; no Google evidence | |
| 77.1.238.255 | no | odd - added false start date to ChildWiki; no Google evidence |
No more possibly related IP edits seen in the last 99 days, back to 11 December 2013.
