WikiIndex talk:Opt out: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(response to Mark) |
Hoof Hearted (talk | contribs) (Fix rediect) |
||
| (7 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
This doesn't need to be a meta level page. [[MarkDilley]] | <small>[[User talk:MarkDilley|talk]]</small> 18:48, 11 Mar 2006 (EST) | {{TOC right}} | ||
: Mark, you and I often see things differently. I love that. I do. '''And''', it would really help me if you'd say more when expressing that you have a different opinion. I moved the page here so clearly at the time I moved it, I believed the move to be correct, or at least justifiable. I'm happy to try to explain why I did it. I'm not attached to the move and can certainly be convinced otherwise. It would just help a lot if you expressed your reasoning, not just your disagreement. This applies to WikiNode and TourBusStop as well, assuming those anon, unsigned edits on the talk | ==Thoughts== | ||
This doesn't need to be a [[:Category:Meta|meta]] level page. [[MarkDilley]] | <small>[[User talk:MarkDilley|talk]]</small> 18:48, 11 Mar 2006 (EST) | |||
:Mark, you and I often see things differently. I love that. I do. '''And''', it would really help me if you'd say more when expressing that you have a different opinion. I moved the page here so clearly at the time I moved it, I believed the [[move]] to be correct, or at least justifiable. I'm happy to try to explain why I did it. I'm not attached to the move and can certainly be convinced otherwise. It would just help a lot if you expressed your reasoning, not just your disagreement. This applies to [[WikiNode]] and [[TourBusStop]] as well, assuming those anon, unsigned edits on the [[talk page]]s were also yours. Thanks so much! [[TedErnst]] | <small>[[User talk:TedErnst|talk]]</small> 02:49, 12 Mar 2006 (EST) | |||
::Originally this page was [[Opt out]]. It was moved to [[WikiIndex:Opt out]] because it's about a WikiIndex guideline. Today I split the page into [[Opt out]] for the general concept and [[WikiIndex:Opt out]] for the guideline. [[TedErnst]] | <small>[[User talk:TedErnst|talk]]</small> 13:27, 13 Mar 2006 (EST) | |||
==Where actually is the said guideline?== | |||
Obviously there is not sufficient guideline. Therefore it can be misunderstood. Clearly even purported well versed and experienced local [[User]]s like [[User:Leucosticte]] can get it wrong as You can see here: [[Talk:Theshatteredpan.org]]. | |||
For example it seams not to be clear, that 'wiki [[owner]] or community' does not refer to registrant of the domain. [[User:Manorainjan|Manorainjan]] ([[User talk:Manorainjan|talk]]) 14:32, 4 September 2014 (UTC) | |||
==Criteria and verification== | |||
Since we certainly would not want every little [[troll]] to be able to delete wiki pages that we carefully created, I see the need to verify the validity of the request. For example the [[leader]] of the Wiki in question would have to make the request. And to verify the validity he/she/it would have to repeat this request on their Wiki under the name of that leader. That, of course, would seemingly make it impossible for dead Wikis to opt out ;-) Only in case of a dead [[:Category:Bliki|bliki]] it should be possible to verify the identity of the leader, because "There could be only one" and that one would easily be identifiabel. [[User:Manorainjan|Manorainjan]] ([[User talk:Manorainjan|talk]]) 14:45, 4 September 2014 (UTC) | |||
Latest revision as of 14:57, 21 January 2023
Thoughts[edit]
This doesn't need to be a meta level page. MarkDilley | talk 18:48, 11 Mar 2006 (EST)
- Mark, you and I often see things differently. I love that. I do. And, it would really help me if you'd say more when expressing that you have a different opinion. I moved the page here so clearly at the time I moved it, I believed the move to be correct, or at least justifiable. I'm happy to try to explain why I did it. I'm not attached to the move and can certainly be convinced otherwise. It would just help a lot if you expressed your reasoning, not just your disagreement. This applies to WikiNode and TourBusStop as well, assuming those anon, unsigned edits on the talk pages were also yours. Thanks so much! TedErnst | talk 02:49, 12 Mar 2006 (EST)
- Originally this page was Opt out. It was moved to WikiIndex:Opt out because it's about a WikiIndex guideline. Today I split the page into Opt out for the general concept and WikiIndex:Opt out for the guideline. TedErnst | talk 13:27, 13 Mar 2006 (EST)
Where actually is the said guideline?[edit]
Obviously there is not sufficient guideline. Therefore it can be misunderstood. Clearly even purported well versed and experienced local Users like User:Leucosticte can get it wrong as You can see here: Talk:Theshatteredpan.org.
For example it seams not to be clear, that 'wiki owner or community' does not refer to registrant of the domain. Manorainjan (talk) 14:32, 4 September 2014 (UTC)
Criteria and verification[edit]
Since we certainly would not want every little troll to be able to delete wiki pages that we carefully created, I see the need to verify the validity of the request. For example the leader of the Wiki in question would have to make the request. And to verify the validity he/she/it would have to repeat this request on their Wiki under the name of that leader. That, of course, would seemingly make it impossible for dead Wikis to opt out ;-) Only in case of a dead bliki it should be possible to verify the identity of the leader, because "There could be only one" and that one would easily be identifiabel. Manorainjan (talk) 14:45, 4 September 2014 (UTC)