Talk:Conservapedia: Difference between revisions
Lengthy criticisms
(→Separating RationalWiki criticism: Where to put it) |
(Lengthy criticisms) |
||
| Line 29: | Line 29: | ||
:Sounds fair. Though should "The War" go under CP or RW? Or does it need it's own article - "Wiki wars" or whatever? Such an article might also refer to Librapedia, RWW, Creation Wiki Evowiki and Atheism.wikia. Or would such an article run counter to the ethos of this site?--[[User:Bob M|Bob M]] 09:12, 11 August 2008 (EDT) | :Sounds fair. Though should "The War" go under CP or RW? Or does it need it's own article - "Wiki wars" or whatever? Such an article might also refer to Librapedia, RWW, Creation Wiki Evowiki and Atheism.wikia. Or would such an article run counter to the ethos of this site?--[[User:Bob M|Bob M]] 09:12, 11 August 2008 (EDT) | ||
::I lean towards putting it under CP. The war tends to be '''about''' CP but '''by''' RW. Most of what would go into the section would describe CP, so that's where it belongs. A mention and link in the RW article, of course. As far as a separate article, or even a category of such, I'm too new a user here to take that step. Is that something this site should be going into? Not for me to say. [[User:William Ackerman|William Ackerman]] 14:23, 14 August 2008 (EDT) | ::I lean towards putting it under CP. The war tends to be '''about''' CP but '''by''' RW. Most of what would go into the section would describe CP, so that's where it belongs. A mention and link in the RW article, of course. As far as a separate article, or even a category of such, I'm too new a user here to take that step. Is that something this site should be going into? Not for me to say. [[User:William Ackerman|William Ackerman]] 14:23, 14 August 2008 (EDT) | ||
== Lengthy criticisms == | |||
I dislike CP as well, but Wikiindex seems to be, well, an index: a very short description of the wikis, some technical details, some links. CP is unique in that it has a ''whole entire wiki'' dedicated to criticizing it and drawing attention to its worst abuses and most comical moments. Isn't that sort of thing beyond the scope of this site? [[User:74.7.166.234|74.7.166.234]] 14:42, 13 November 2008 (EST) | |||