User talk:MarkDilley: Difference between revisions

User talk:MarkDilley (edit)

716 bytes added , 23 May 2009

Answer to 'Dicuss, warn, or block?'

211

edits

@@ Line 1,297: / Line 1,297: @@
 ::As far as the canon/fanon issue, I think I created a [[:Category:Fanon]] a while back. Whoops, nope, it wasn't me, but someone else did. There's also a few wikis tagged with the non-existant [[:Category:Fandoms]]. Taxonomy around here is from the ground up, although I've done some sorting just to try and lump like items together. I don't think there's a [[:Category:Canon]], but there could be. Regardless, that's totally appropriate info to add to a wiki's article. --[[User:MarvelZuvembie|MarvelZuvembie]] 18:59, 9 May 2009 (EDT)
+:::It would take ages for someone to shoot around looking for all the wikis that should be added to [[:Category:Canon]]. I know that [[Wookiepedia]] and [[Memory Alpha]] (and [[Memory Beta]]) contain canon (of [[:Categeory:Star Wars]] and [[:Category:Star Trek]]), but you need someone with geek-level knowledge of the subject matter to make the judgement call.
+:::As for [[:Category:Fandoms]] that has got to be slightly different to [[:Category:Fanon]]. There are plenty of things that fans ''might'' do that do not involve canon or fanon. Maybe [[:Category:Fandoms]] should be the parent category to [[:Category:Canon]] and [[:Category:Fanon]]. [[User:David Shepheard|David Shepheard]] 07:17, 23 May 2009 (EDT)
 == Arbitrary celebration ==