83,675
edits
Category talk:Wiki status: Difference between revisions
→Category:Private is not consistent a member of Wiki Status: fix red link following page rename
Hoof Hearted (talk | contribs) m (Text replacement - "{{TOCright}}" to "{{TOC right}}") |
Hoof Hearted (talk | contribs) (→Category:Private is not consistent a member of Wiki Status: fix red link following page rename) |
||
| Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
:''(imported from [[WikiIndex talk:Community portal]])'' | :''(imported from [[WikiIndex talk:Community portal]])'' | ||
[[User:Manorainjan|Manorainjan]] posed an interesting question on my talk page, which ought to be thrown open to the wider community; his question quoted as follows: | [[User:Manorainjan|Manorainjan]] posed an interesting question on my talk page, which ought to be thrown open to the wider community; his question quoted as follows: | ||
<blockquote>I think here is a change needed. A wiki could be dormant and private at the same time like [[Bible Wiki ( | <blockquote>I think here is a change needed. A wiki could be dormant and private at the same time like [[Bible Wiki (BibleWiki.net)]]. Private belongs to another aspect similar to editmode. One has to create the aspect "accessibility" or anything else.<br>{public|private|onInvitation|adult|legitimation|etc.} which defines the scope of onlookers not of editors. Naturally the scope of editmode is narrower than "accessibility" the mode nnames would have quite a cut set. [[User:Manorainjan|Manorainjan]] ([[User talk:Manorainjan|talk]]) 21:01, 4 August 2014 (UTC)</blockquote> | ||
So basically, should [[:Category:Private]] remain a sub-category of [[:Category:Wiki Status]], or should Category:Private be a sub-cat of [[:Category:Wiki Edit Mode]] – or even both? Manorainjan expresses good rationale for a change, and I'm inclined to support him. Another example which lends support for change, is that a wiki can be private, but can also have viggorous activity – which might place it in the [[:Category:Vibrant]] sub-cat of Wiki Status. I think if we do move Category:Private under the Category:Wiki Edit Mode umbrella, then it could even be a sub-cat of [[:Category:ByInvitation]]? | So basically, should [[:Category:Private]] remain a sub-category of [[:Category:Wiki Status]], or should Category:Private be a sub-cat of [[:Category:Wiki Edit Mode]] – or even both? Manorainjan expresses good rationale for a change, and I'm inclined to support him. Another example which lends support for change, is that a wiki can be private, but can also have viggorous activity – which might place it in the [[:Category:Vibrant]] sub-cat of Wiki Status. I think if we do move Category:Private under the Category:Wiki Edit Mode umbrella, then it could even be a sub-cat of [[:Category:ByInvitation]]? | ||