Talk:The Conservapedia RationalWiki war: Difference between revisions

:::What is this wiki about? Is it about directing people towards wikis, or providing (one sided) criticisms of wikis? I checked out a couple popular wikis as a way to compare and see what a "good" wikiindex article would be. [[English Wikipedia]], '''the''' wiki, is described as "The English language Wikipedia, free encyclopedia that anyone can edit, neutral point of view, NPOV". [[Uncyclopedia]] has no criticism, [[Encyclopædia Dramatica]] has no criticism. [[RationalWiki]] has a "criticism" section, but it's used to criticise Conservapedia. The only criticism section I can find is in [[AboutUs]], but it is stated in plain, non-inflamatory language, and AboutUs was given a chance to refute the criticism section. My "bias" doesn't change these facts, does it? [[User:Jazzman831|Jazz]][[User talk:Jazzman831|Man]] 18:48, 15 November 2008 (EST)

What's this article for? I thought that this was supposed to be an online wiki phonebook, not a place for wikis to criticize each other. This will grow out of control. Someone might try to make a [[Wookieepedia]] vs. [[Star Wars Fanon]] article, an [[Uncyclopedia]] vs. [[Illogicopedia]] article, or even an [[Uncyclopedia]]/ [[Illogicopedia]] vs. [[Wikia]] article. --[[User:Michaeldsuarez|Michaeldsuarez]] 00:03, 16 November 2008 (EST)