1,136
edits
User talk:Lumenos: Difference between revisions
→Reordering talk page comments
(→wow) |
|||
| Line 54: | Line 54: | ||
Lumenos, whatever you mean by a "debate map" is not clear to others with plenty of wiki talk page experience. Turning it into something ''you'' think makes sense does not do respect to other editors and the format and style of their editing. A good rule to follow: don't edit others' talk page comments. Simply don't. Add your own, quote them, respond to the them, but leave their edits alone. [[User:Huw Powell|Huw Powell]] 23:38, 4 September 2009 (EDT) | Lumenos, whatever you mean by a "debate map" is not clear to others with plenty of wiki talk page experience. Turning it into something ''you'' think makes sense does not do respect to other editors and the format and style of their editing. A good rule to follow: don't edit others' talk page comments. Simply don't. Add your own, quote them, respond to the them, but leave their edits alone. [[User:Huw Powell|Huw Powell]] 23:38, 4 September 2009 (EDT) | ||
:Your prayers have been answered. I've moved the [[Talk:RationalWiki/Debate_maps|unfun house to a subpage]] and placed warning signs on the entry ways. BEWARE THE MADDENING [http://lumeniki.referata.com/wiki/Ikilumen IKILUMEN]! Howevar, in my perception, the arguments I present in [[Talk:RationalWiki#See_also|the following sections]] were spot on: | |||
15 Edit wars | |||
16 Similar wikis | |||
17 Criticism and rebuttals | |||
17.1 RationalWiki vs Wikipedia | |||
17.2 An very rare example of Lumenos misunderstanding | |||
17.3 Does Wikipedia achieve the aims of RationalWiki better than RationalWiki? | |||
18 Put a comparisons of wikis section in the RationalWiki article | |||
19 On what features or qualities should we compare any wikis (or these wikis in particular)? | |||
20 Should A Storehouse of Knowledge (ASK) be included as a "similar wiki" or in a comparison table? | |||
21 Should Wikipedia be included in the comparison table? | |||
22 Notification of the service failure | |||
If I have not destroyed all trust in my abilities to reason, your feedback on the accuracy of this perception, would be appreciated. ~~ [[User:Lumenos|Lumenos]] | |||
==Create a guideline for editing talk pages== | ==Create a guideline for editing talk pages== | ||