Category talk:Active administrators of this wiki/Archive 2012-13: Difference between revisions

m
m (Protected "Category talk:Active administrators of this wiki/Archive 2012-13": High traffic/importance page ([Edit=Registered only] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite)))
Line 120: Line 120:


Another suggestion would be to make registration under real names (without [[CamelCase]]) compulsory.  I accept that may deter folks, but as it stands at the moment, I have great difficulty in trying to determine the difference between an 'acceptable alias' username, and that of a pure spambot.  If forcing real names is not an option, then just ban CamelCase name registration, ban underscore, special characters and numbers in username registration - if someone desparately wants to be known by fancy characters and the likes, they can overcome that by creating a [[signature]] in their profile, or even creating a new [[user page]] with an incoming [[redirect]].  Maybe if we had [[mw:Extension:Renameuser]], then any accounts created could be then subsequently changed to something more preferable to the individual.
Another suggestion would be to make registration under real names (without [[CamelCase]]) compulsory.  I accept that may deter folks, but as it stands at the moment, I have great difficulty in trying to determine the difference between an 'acceptable alias' username, and that of a pure spambot.  If forcing real names is not an option, then just ban CamelCase name registration, ban underscore, special characters and numbers in username registration - if someone desparately wants to be known by fancy characters and the likes, they can overcome that by creating a [[signature]] in their profile, or even creating a new [[user page]] with an incoming [[redirect]].  Maybe if we had [[mw:Extension:Renameuser]], then any accounts created could be then subsequently changed to something more preferable to the individual.
: I like for people to use [[Real Name]]s, however I don't like to force people to do that. ~~ [[MarkDilley]]
: I like for people to use [[WikiIndex:Real names|real names]], however I don't like to force people to do that. ~~ [[MarkDilley]]


A final suggestion is to enable [[:Category:ConfirmEmail|confirm e-mail]] for account creation.  Ha-ha . . . I hear my ears burning with Mark's ethos of [[:Category:OpenEdit|open editing]]!  Well, we will still have open editing from [[IP editors]] (and those have to go through Captcha on every edit they make) - the whole reason spambots create accounts is so that they bypass the edit Captcha.  Having to confirm e-mail will virtually eliminate spambot account creation.  One big problem with this - something is wrong with the whole WikiIndex e-mail system . . . I've never been able to get e-mail working, and others have also reported this . . .
A final suggestion is to enable [[:Category:ConfirmEmail|confirm e-mail]] for account creation.  Ha-ha . . . I hear my ears burning with Mark's ethos of [[:Category:OpenEdit|open editing]]!  Well, we will still have open editing from [[IP editors]] (and those have to go through Captcha on every edit they make) - the whole reason spambots create accounts is so that they bypass the edit Captcha.  Having to confirm e-mail will virtually eliminate spambot account creation.  One big problem with this - something is wrong with the whole WikiIndex e-mail system . . . I've never been able to get e-mail working, and others have also reported this . . .