User talk:Hoof Hearted/Archive2 - 2012: Difference between revisions

 
Line 84: Line 84:


==Blocking old IPs==
==Blocking old IPs==
It's been 5 years since any of those IPs vandalized the site, so there is pretty much no chance that they are used by the same person. I personally don't think [[IP address]]es should be banned for more then a month unless there is persistent vandalism over a very long period of time from it.  
It's been 5 years since any of those IPs vandalized the site, so there is pretty much no chance that they are used by the same person. I personally don't think [[IP address]]es should be banned for more then a month unless there is persistent [[vandal]]ism over a very long period of time from it.  


As for Plasmarelais, I don't think there was any malicious intent involved there - the redirect worked because of the site's [[Special:interwiki|interwiki]] feature. '''[[User talk:Elassint|Elassint]]'''  14 September 2012
As for Plasmarelais, I don't think there was any malicious intent involved there - the redirect worked because of the site's [[Special:interwiki|interwiki]] feature. '''[[User talk:Elassint|Elassint]]'''  14 September 2012
:Blocking old IPs . . . yes, I suppose you are correct on that.  In my defence, I'm using a netbook, and I often miss the bottom of the page (forget to scroll down) on my woefully small screen.  I've noticed that many had been previously blocked for short-term periods.  I'll refrain from this from now on. :)
:Blocking old IPs . . . yes, I suppose you are correct on that.  In my defence, I'm using a netbook, and I often miss the bottom of the page (forget to scroll down) on my woefully small screen.  I've noticed that many had been previously blocked for short-term periods.  I'll refrain from this from now on. :)
:Re [[User:Plasmarelais|Plasmarelais]] - I'm not at all convinced of any 'innocence'.  Plasmarelais is an admin on Wikia - and is no doubt very aware of the intricate nature of combining a 'redirect' with an 'interwiki'.  IMVHO, that was quite a sneaky thing to do - and it took me a while to figure out how to 'undo' a new page creation (with no history) which went straight to a hard redirect.  The correct and decent thing would be to just have a common-or-garden http:// url to his Wikia page - not the forced redirect!  Finally, why just create a forced redirect to another wiki site, but not carry out any constructive editing to this wiki?  Rgds  [[User:Hoof Hearted|Hoof Hearted]] • <small>[[User talk:Hoof Hearted|talk2HH]]</small> 13:39, 14 September 2012 (PDT)
:Re [[Special:Contributions/Plasmarelais|Plasmarelais]] - I'm not at all convinced of any 'innocence'.  Plasmarelais is an admin on Wikia - and is no doubt very aware of the intricate nature of combining a 'redirect' with an 'interwiki'.  IMVHO, that was quite a sneaky thing to do - and it took me a while to figure out how to 'undo' a new page creation (with no history) which went straight to a hard redirect.  The correct and decent thing would be to just have a common-or-garden http:// url to his Wikia page - not the forced redirect!  Finally, why just create a forced redirect to another wiki site, but not carry out any constructive editing to this wiki?  Rgds  [[User:Hoof Hearted|Hoof Hearted]] • <small>[[User talk:Hoof Hearted|talk2HH]]</small> 13:39, 14 September 2012 (PDT)


==E-mail notification subject==
==E-mail notification subject==