Talk:Proposal:Category tree: Difference between revisions

Talk:Proposal:Category tree (edit)

Revision as of 03:49, 29 January 2008

3 bytes added , 29 January 2008

m

forgot word ("at")

EarthFurst

Administrators

1,317

edits

Revision as of 03:48, 29 January 2008 (edit) EarthFurst (talk \| contribs) (What are Main Topics ?) ← Older edit		Revision as of 03:49, 29 January 2008 (edit) (undo) EarthFurst (talk \| contribs) m (forgot word ("at")) Newer edit →
Line 1:		Line 1:
	I am very confused by the topics part of Proposal:CategoryTree. The Proposal 6.13.06 Category Tree image has "Main Topic" with subtopics (referred to as "Topic"s). '''I'm wondering which topics qualify as "Main Topic"s''' and which topics are only "Topics" (aka subtopics). Is Sex a Main Topic or subtopic? Is Sexuality a Main Topic or subtopic? For comparison, I looked '''part''' of a category tree at Wikipedia: Category:LGBT is a subcat of Sexual orientation, Sexual orientation is a subcat of Sexual attraction, Sexual attraction is a subcat of Sexuality, Sexuality is a subcat of Sex. And wikipedia's Sex category is a subcategory of the Reproduction, Genetics and Reproductive system categories.		I am very confused by the topics part of Proposal:CategoryTree. The Proposal 6.13.06 Category Tree image has "Main Topic" with subtopics (referred to as "Topic"s). '''I'm wondering which topics qualify as "Main Topic"s''' and which topics are only "Topics" (aka subtopics). Is Sex a Main Topic or subtopic? Is Sexuality a Main Topic or subtopic? For comparison, I looked at '''part''' of a category tree at Wikipedia: Category:LGBT is a subcat of Sexual orientation, Sexual orientation is a subcat of Sexual attraction, Sexual attraction is a subcat of Sexuality, Sexuality is a subcat of Sex. And wikipedia's Sex category is a subcategory of the Reproduction, Genetics and Reproductive system categories.
	Does LGBT qualify as a Main Topic? (There are various LGBT wikis) Or/and should Category:LGBT be a subcategory of Category:Sexuality (Should Category:Sex be empty with "Sex" wikis reclassified as "Sexuality" wikis? --[[User:EarthFurst\|EarthFurst]] 22:48, 28 January 2008 (EST)		Does LGBT qualify as a Main Topic? (There are various LGBT wikis) Or/and should Category:LGBT be a subcategory of Category:Sexuality (Should Category:Sex be empty with "Sex" wikis reclassified as "Sexuality" wikis? --[[User:EarthFurst\|EarthFurst]] 22:48, 28 January 2008 (EST)