83,675
edits
WikiIndex talk:Opt out: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
m
top section heading, additional wikilinks, TOCright
Manorainjan (talk | contribs) (→Criteria and verification: new section) |
Hoof Hearted (talk | contribs) m (top section heading, additional wikilinks, TOCright) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
This doesn't need to be a meta level page. [[MarkDilley]] | <small>[[User talk:MarkDilley|talk]]</small> 18:48, 11 Mar 2006 (EST) | {{TOCright}} | ||
: Mark, you and I often see things differently. I love that. I do. '''And''', it would really help me if you'd say more when expressing that you have a different opinion. I moved the page here so clearly at the time I moved it, I believed the move to be correct, or at least justifiable. I'm happy to try to explain why I did it. I'm not attached to the move and can certainly be convinced otherwise. It would just help a lot if you expressed your reasoning, not just your disagreement. This applies to WikiNode and TourBusStop as well, assuming those anon, unsigned edits on the talk | ==Thoughts== | ||
Originally this page was [[OptOut]]. It was moved to [[WikiIndex:OptOut]] because it's about a WikiIndex guideline. Today I split the page into [[OptOut]] for the general concept and [[WikiIndex:OptOut]] for the guideline. [[TedErnst]] | <small>[[User talk:TedErnst|talk]]</small> 13:27, 13 Mar 2006 (EST) | This doesn't need to be a [[:Category:Meta|meta]] level page. [[MarkDilley]] | <small>[[User talk:MarkDilley|talk]]</small> 18:48, 11 Mar 2006 (EST) | ||
:Mark, you and I often see things differently. I love that. I do. '''And''', it would really help me if you'd say more when expressing that you have a different opinion. I moved the page here so clearly at the time I moved it, I believed the [[move]] to be correct, or at least justifiable. I'm happy to try to explain why I did it. I'm not attached to the move and can certainly be convinced otherwise. It would just help a lot if you expressed your reasoning, not just your disagreement. This applies to [[WikiNode]] and [[TourBusStop]] as well, assuming those anon, unsigned edits on the [[talk page]]s were also yours. Thanks so much! [[TedErnst]] | <small>[[User talk:TedErnst|talk]]</small> 02:49, 12 Mar 2006 (EST) | |||
::Originally this page was [[OptOut]]. It was moved to [[WikiIndex:OptOut]] because it's about a WikiIndex guideline. Today I split the page into [[OptOut]] for the general concept and [[WikiIndex:OptOut]] for the guideline. [[TedErnst]] | <small>[[User talk:TedErnst|talk]]</small> 13:27, 13 Mar 2006 (EST) | |||
== Where actually is the said guideline? == | ==Where actually is the said guideline?== | ||
Obviously there is not sufficient guideline. Therefore it can be misunderstood. Clearly even purported well versed and experienced local [[User]]s like [[User:Leucosticte]] can get it wrong as You can see here: [[Talk:Theshatteredpan.org]]. | |||
For example it seams not to be clear, that 'wiki owner or community' does not refer to registrant of the domain. | |||
[[User:Manorainjan|Manorainjan]] ([[User talk:Manorainjan|talk]]) 14:32, 4 September 2014 (UTC) | |||
==Criteria and verification== | |||
Since we certainly would not want every little [[troll]] to be able to delete wiki pages that we carefully created, I see the need to verify the validity of the request. For example the [[leader]] of the Wiki in question would have to make the request. And to verify the validity he/she/it would have to repeat this request on their Wiki under the name of that leader. that, of course, would seemingly make it impossible for dead Wikis to opt out ;-) Only in case of a dead [[bliki]] it should be possible to verify the identity of the leader, because "There could be only one" and that one would easily be identifiabel. [[User:Manorainjan|Manorainjan]] ([[User talk:Manorainjan|talk]]) 14:45, 4 September 2014 (UTC) | |||
== Criteria and verification == | |||
Since we certainly would not want every little troll to be able to delete wiki pages that we carefully created, I see the need to verify the validity of the request. For example the [[leader]] of the Wiki in question would have to make the request. And to verify the validity he/she/it would have to repeat this request on their Wiki under the name of that leader. that, of course, would seemingly make it impossible for dead Wikis to opt out ;-) Only in case of a dead [[bliki]] it should be possible to verify the identity of the leader, because "There could be only one" and that one would easily be identifiabel. [[User:Manorainjan|Manorainjan]] ([[User talk:Manorainjan|talk]]) 14:45, 4 September 2014 (UTC) | |||