Bureaucrats, checkuser, Interface administrators, interwiki, Administrators (Semantic MediaWiki), Curators (Semantic MediaWiki), Editors (Semantic MediaWiki), staff, Suppressors, Administrators
83,693
edits
WikiIndex talk:About: Difference between revisions
m
Text replacement - "Category:WikiIdea" to "Category:Wiki idea"
Hoof Hearted (talk | contribs) m (Text replacement - "Wiki Age" to "Wiki age") |
Hoof Hearted (talk | contribs) m (Text replacement - "Category:WikiIdea" to "Category:Wiki idea") |
||
| Line 50: | Line 50: | ||
Do you mean that it's not a general [[:Category:Encyclopedia|encyclopedia]], or that it's not even an encyclopedia of [[wiki]]s? When I think of an encyclopedia, I think of a site that, even though it may restrict its scope to certain topics, will cover those topics thoroughly (hence the name "encyclopedia"; "encyclopedic" mean "comprehensive in terms of information"). [[:Category:Wikipedia|Wikipedia]] deletes a lot of articles for non-notability, but once it decides to have an article on a topic, it tends to go all-out; e.g. {{Wp|White & Nerdy#Music video}} contains a lot of information that could be considered [[cruft]] (they've actually dialed it back a bit, because it used to contain even more information; but still, there's a lot of stuff there that could be considered trivia). | Do you mean that it's not a general [[:Category:Encyclopedia|encyclopedia]], or that it's not even an encyclopedia of [[wiki]]s? When I think of an encyclopedia, I think of a site that, even though it may restrict its scope to certain topics, will cover those topics thoroughly (hence the name "encyclopedia"; "encyclopedic" mean "comprehensive in terms of information"). [[:Category:Wikipedia|Wikipedia]] deletes a lot of articles for non-notability, but once it decides to have an article on a topic, it tends to go all-out; e.g. {{Wp|White & Nerdy#Music video}} contains a lot of information that could be considered [[cruft]] (they've actually dialed it back a bit, because it used to contain even more information; but still, there's a lot of stuff there that could be considered trivia). | ||
But it seems like WikiIndex wants to limit its entries to basic facts about the [[WhatIsWiki|wikis]] and [[:Category:Wiki People|wiki people]] in question. (There aren't a lot of articles here about [[:Category: | But it seems like WikiIndex wants to limit its entries to basic facts about the [[WhatIsWiki|wikis]] and [[:Category:Wiki People|wiki people]] in question. (There aren't a lot of articles here about [[:Category:Wiki idea|wiki ideas]], and none of those articles are very long, so there's not much precedent to show how a lengthy article about a wiki idea would be handled; but we've had a few long articles about wikis and wiki people, which were cut down). The solution is usually, in the case of pages about wikis, to link to an off-wiki [[about page]]; or in the case of wiki people, to link to an off-wiki [[user page]]. | ||
If that's the direction you want to go in, fine. The site is, after all, Wiki "Index"; an index usually only contains very short blurbs, with a few statistics, about its subject matter. But we should clarify this in the about page, so people know. | If that's the direction you want to go in, fine. The site is, after all, Wiki "Index"; an index usually only contains very short blurbs, with a few statistics, about its subject matter. But we should clarify this in the about page, so people know. | ||