1,136
edits
User talk:Huw Powell: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
→Censoring dissenting opinion: redundancy removal
(→Censoring dissenting opinion: sorry, found that you had indeed posted a sort of "rebuttal") |
(→Censoring dissenting opinion: redundancy removal) |
||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
Hello again, I'm writing in reference to your recent edit of the [[RationalWiki]] article, wherein you removed the link to the following argument. "[[Talk:RationalWiki#Criticism_and_rebuttals|Wikipedia achieves the stated goals of RationalWiki better than RationalWiki does]]". Your edit summary was, "11:08, 1 September 2009 [...] (Lumenos, please whine on the talk page.)" <del>Did you read the argument? [[User:Lumenos|Lumenos]] 10:04, 1 September 2009 (EDT)</del> | Hello again, I'm writing in reference to your recent edit of the [[RationalWiki]] article, wherein you removed the link to the following argument. "[[Talk:RationalWiki#Criticism_and_rebuttals|Wikipedia achieves the stated goals of RationalWiki better than RationalWiki does]]". Your edit summary was, "11:08, 1 September 2009 [...] (Lumenos, please whine on the talk page.)" <del>Did you read the argument? [[User:Lumenos|Lumenos]] 10:04, 1 September 2009 (EDT)</del> | ||
:I'm sorry, I found that you had in fact replied, but due to the location (and the general disorganization of talk pages) I neglected to notice it until now. I have answered your rebuttal and I will give you some time to formulate a response (if you should wish to do so) before adding the critical comment back to the article or perhaps to another article entitled [[Criticism of RationalWiki]], in keeping with [[WikiIndex:Policies_and_Guidelines#How_sympathetic_or_critical.3F_.28Who_decides.3F.29|what little consensus we have garnered thus far]] | :I'm sorry, I found that you had in fact replied, but due to the location (and the general disorganization of talk pages) I neglected to notice it until now. I have answered your rebuttal and I will give you some time to formulate a response (if you should wish to do so) before adding the critical comment back to the article or perhaps to another article entitled [[Criticism of RationalWiki]], in keeping with [[WikiIndex:Policies_and_Guidelines#How_sympathetic_or_critical.3F_.28Who_decides.3F.29|what little consensus we have garnered thus far]]. [[User:Lumenos|Lumenos]] 14:50, 1 September 2009 (EDT) | ||
Secondly, if you have any suggestions for why [[WikiIndex]] should not allow certain criticisms, or how to objectively judge which ones should or should not be allowed, your reasoning on this matter would be appreciated in [[WikiIndex:Policies_and_Guidelines#How_sympathetic_or_critical.3F_.28Who_decides.3F.29|this section of the policy page]]. [[User:Lumenos|Lumenos]] 10:03, 1 September 2009 (EDT) | Secondly, if you have any suggestions for why [[WikiIndex]] should not allow certain criticisms, or how to objectively judge which ones should or should not be allowed, your reasoning on this matter would be appreciated in [[WikiIndex:Policies_and_Guidelines#How_sympathetic_or_critical.3F_.28Who_decides.3F.29|this section of the policy page]]. [[User:Lumenos|Lumenos]] 10:03, 1 September 2009 (EDT) | ||