Template:Wikipedia / Wikinfo / Wikia / WikiKnowledge — comparison table: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Hoof Hearted (talk | contribs) (loads more info, additional fields in table, fix/update links, interwiki links) |
Hoof Hearted (talk | contribs) (→Table: more updates) |
||
| Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
{|class="wikitable" style=text-align:center | {|class="wikitable" style=text-align:center | ||
|- | |- | ||
! !!<big>[[:Category:Wikipedia|Wikipedia]]</big><br><small>(info for<br>[[English Wikipedia]])</small>!!<big>[[Wikinfo]]</big>!!<big>[[:Category:Wikia|Wikia]]</big><br><small>(for all [[:Category:Wiki Language|languages]])</small>!!<big>[[WikiKnowledge]]</big><br><small>(dead wiki –<br>as of Oct 2008)</small> | ! !!<big>[[:Category:Wikipedia|Wikipedia]]</big><br><small>(info for<br>[[English Wikipedia]])</small>!!<big>[[Wikinfo]]</big><br><small>(from 2014 timeslice<br>of lost wiki)</small>!!<big>[[:Category:Wikia|Wikia]]</big><br><small>(for all [[:Category:Wiki Language|languages]])</small>!!<big>[[WikiKnowledge]]</big><br><small>(dead wiki –<br>as of Oct 2008)</small> | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''[[:Category:Wiki Size|size<br>(number of articles)]]||[[wp:Special:Statistics|>4,054,000]]<br><small>(originally seeded from<br>''1911 Encyclopedia Britannica'')</small>||[https://archive.is/AMibZ 6,166]<br><small>(mostly imported from<br>En-Wp and little modified)</small>||[http://www.wikia.com/Special:Search?search=List+of+Wikia >13,200]<br><small>(stats unofficial, based on<br>WikiIndex Wikia category)</small>||[[Archive.org:20081011115633/http://WikiKnowledge.net/wiki/Special:Statistics|1,950]] | |'''[[:Category:Wiki Size|size<br>(number of articles)]]||[[wp:Special:Statistics|>4,054,000]]<br><small>(originally seeded from<br>''1911 Encyclopedia Britannica'')</small>||[https://archive.is/AMibZ 6,166]<br><small>(mostly imported from<br>En-Wp and little modified)</small>||[http://www.wikia.com/Special:Search?search=List+of+Wikia >13,200]<br><small>(stats unofficial, based on<br>WikiIndex Wikia category)</small>||[[Archive.org:20081011115633/http://WikiKnowledge.net/wiki/Special:Statistics|1,950]] | ||
| Line 18: | Line 18: | ||
|'''[[Bureaucrat|'Crats]] / [[Sysop|admins]] / reg. [[user]]s||[[wp:Special:Statistics|?? / >1,460 / >17,490,000]]||[https://archive.is/AMibZ 2 / 8 / 3,111]||?? / ??? / ????||?? / 7 / 100 | |'''[[Bureaucrat|'Crats]] / [[Sysop|admins]] / reg. [[user]]s||[[wp:Special:Statistics|?? / >1,460 / >17,490,000]]||[https://archive.is/AMibZ 2 / 8 / 3,111]||?? / ??? / ????||?? / 7 / 100 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''[[:Category:Wiki Edit Mode|who can edit]]||[[:Category:OpenEdit|anonymous]]||[[:Category: | |'''[[:Category:Wiki Edit Mode|who can edit]]||[[:Category:OpenEdit|anonymous]]||[[:Category:ByInvitation|invitation only]]||[[:Category:OpenEdit|anonymous]]||[[:Category:LoginToEdit|registered only]] | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''[[:Category:Wiki License|license of content]]||[[GNU Free Documentation License|GFDL]] / [[:Category:Wiki Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike|CC-BY-SA 3.0]]||[[:Category:Wiki Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike|CC-BY-SA 3.0]]||[[:Category:Wiki Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike|CC-BY-SA 3.0]]||[[:Category:Wiki Public Domain (generic)|PD - public domain]] | |'''[[:Category:Wiki License|license of content]]||[[GNU Free Documentation License|GFDL]] / [[:Category:Wiki Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike|CC-BY-SA 3.0]]||[[:Category:Wiki Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike|CC-BY-SA 3.0]]||[[:Category:Wiki Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike|CC-BY-SA 3.0]]||[[:Category:Wiki Public Domain (generic)|PD - public domain]] | ||
| Line 30: | Line 30: | ||
|'''[[:Category:Point of view|point of view]] (POV)||[[Neutral point of view|NPOV]]||[[Archive.org:20160415113736/http://Wikinfo.org/w/English/index.php/Wikinfo:Sympathetic_point_of_view|SPOV]]||???||NPOV | |'''[[:Category:Point of view|point of view]] (POV)||[[Neutral point of view|NPOV]]||[[Archive.org:20160415113736/http://Wikinfo.org/w/English/index.php/Wikinfo:Sympathetic_point_of_view|SPOV]]||???||NPOV | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''[[WikiIndex:Verifiable|standard]]||[[wp:Wikipedia:Verifiability|verifiable]]||truth|| | |'''[[WikiIndex:Verifiable|standard]]||[[wp:Wikipedia:Verifiability|verifiable]]||verifiable truth||no requirement||truth? | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''notability||[[wp:Wikipedia:Notability|non-notable excluded]]||inclusive||anything goes||inclusive | |'''notability||[[wp:Wikipedia:Notability|non-notable excluded]]||inclusive||anything goes||inclusive | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''original research (OR)||[[wp:Wikipedia:No original research|excluded]]|| | |'''original research (OR)||[[wp:Wikipedia:No original research|excluded]]||strongly encouraged||???||OK | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''self-commentary||[[wp:Wikipedia:Conflict of interest|COI discouraged]]||permitted||???||??? | |'''self-commentary||[[wp:Wikipedia:Conflict of interest|COI discouraged]]||permitted||???||??? | ||
Revision as of 03:19, 11 June 2018
- This article needs updating.
Comparison table of policies and other interesting attributes of general-reference wikis written in the English language (with over 1,000 articles).
Table
| Wikipedia (info for English Wikipedia) |
Wikinfo (from 2014 timeslice of lost wiki) |
Wikia (for all languages) |
WikiKnowledge (dead wiki – as of Oct 2008) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| size (number of articles) |
>4,054,000 (originally seeded from 1911 Encyclopedia Britannica) |
6,166 (mostly imported from En-Wp and little modified) |
>13,200 (stats unofficial, based on WikiIndex Wikia category) |
1,950 |
| traffic / SearchEngine ranking | ??? | ??? | ??? | ??? |
| Google PageRank | 9/10 | 0/10 | ?/10 | 0/10 |
| average number edits/day | ~300,000 | ~50 | ??? | ~10 |
| 'Crats / admins / reg. users | ?? / >1,460 / >17,490,000 | 2 / 8 / 3,111 | ?? / ??? / ???? | ?? / 7 / 100 |
| who can edit | anonymous | invitation only | anonymous | registered only |
| license of content | GFDL / CC-BY-SA 3.0 | CC-BY-SA 3.0 | CC-BY-SA 3.0 | PD - public domain |
| non-profit or commercial | non-profit | unknown (personal) | for profit commercial | unknown (personal) |
| funding | free (donations) | ??? | prolific advertising | GoogleAds |
| scope | general-reference | general-reference-plus | general-reference-plus | general-reference-plus |
| point of view (POV) | NPOV | SPOV | ??? | NPOV |
| standard | verifiable | verifiable truth | no requirement | truth? |
| notability | non-notable excluded | inclusive | anything goes | inclusive |
| original research (OR) | excluded | strongly encouraged | ??? | OK |
| self-commentary | COI discouraged | permitted | ??? | ??? |
| offensive material (sexual, violence, profanity) |
permitted | (unresolved) | ??? | no censorship |
| boldness | be bold | be bold, but.. | be bold, be creative | be bold |
| rules | Ignore the rules | read the rules | ??? | read the rules |
| software used ('wiki engine') |
originally UseMod Wiki, now MediaWiki |
was GetWiki, now MediaWiki |
heavily modified MediaWiki |
MediaWiki |
| archived by 3rd party | many unofficial mirrors | yes, WikiTeam | no, internally by Wikia | no |
| database download published online |
yes | Archive.org | some from Wikia article 'Statistics' page |
no |
| founder | Jimmy Wales | Fred Bauder | Jimmy Wales / Angela Beesley |
Gerard Foley |
- Statistics as of 29jan07. If they are more than three-to-six months out of date, please try to update them.
Notes
Anonymous — OpenEdit – anyone can edit content, without registration, including IP editors
Registered only — LoginToEdit – registration required
Invitation only — ByInvitation – typically extremely limited number of editors, usually known personally by founder
GFDL — GNU Free Documentation License – https://www.GNU.org/licenses/fdl.html
NPOV — neutral point of view
SPOV — sympathetic point of view
COI — conflict of interest
https://en.Wikipedia.org • http://www.Wikinfo.org • http://www.WikiKnowledge.net/wiki • http://www.Wikia.com
- other
- http://opencycle.vacommunity.net 61 pages
- future questions
- Archived by https://Archive.org ??
- additional resources