Template:Wikipedia / Wikinfo / Wikia / WikiKnowledge — comparison table: Difference between revisions

From WikiIndex
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(wiki links)
(update with stats - Wikipedia stuff updated - the other two need doing)
Line 1: Line 1:
Comparison table of policies and other interesting attributes of general-reference wikis in English (with over 1,000 articles).
:''This article needs updating.


{| class="wikitable" style="text-align:center"
Comparison table of policies and other interesting attributes of general-reference [[wiki]]s in [[:Category:Wiki English|English]] (with over 1,000 articles).
 
{|class="wikitable" style="text-align:center"
|-
|-
! !! [[Wikipedia]] !! [[Wikinfo]] !! [[Wikiknowledge]]
! !!<big>[[:Category:Wikipedia|Wikipedia]]</big>!!<big>[[WikInfo]]</big>!!<big>[[WikiKnowledge]]</big>
|-
|-
|Size (articles) || 1,608,984 || 35,923<br>(but mostly imported<br>and little modified) || 1,812
|'''[[:Category:Wiki Size|Size (articles)]]||[[wp:Special:Statistics|>3,842,000]]||35,923<br><small>(but mostly imported<br>and little modified)</small>||1,812
|-
|-
|traffic / SearchEngine ranking || ||  
|'''traffic / SearchEngine ranking|| || ||  
|-
|-
|Google PageRank || 9/10 || 0/10 || 0/10
|'''Google PageRank||9/10||0/10||0/10
|-
|-
|Average # edits per day || ~300,000 || ~50 || ~10
|'''[[:Category:Wiki Status|Average # edits per day]]|| ~300,000 || ~50 || ~10
|-
|-
|Admins/Registered users || 1,101/3,389,730 || 26/1,879 || 7/100
|'''[[sysop|Admins]] / Registered users||[[wp:Special:Statistics|>1,500 / >16,000,000]]||26 / 1,879||7 / 100
|-
|-
|Who can edit || Anonymous || Registered only || Anonymous
|'''[[:Category:Wiki Edit Mode|Who can edit]]||[[:Category:OpenEdit|Anonymous]]||[[:Category:LoginToEdit|Registered only]]||[[:Category:OpenEdit|Anonymous]]
|-
|-
|License || GFDL || CC - Creative Commons || PD - Public Domain
|'''[[:Category:Wiki License|License]]||[[GNU Free Documentation License|GFDL]]|| CC - Creative Commons || PD - Public Domain
|-
|-
|Scope || general-reference || general-reference-plus || general-reference-plus
|'''[[:Category:Wiki Topic|Scope]]||[[wp:Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not|general-reference]]||general-reference-plus||general-reference-plus
|-
|-
|POV || NPOV || SPOV || NPOV
|'''[[:Category:PointOfView|Point of view]] (POV)||[[NPOV]]||[[SPOV]]||NPOV
|-
|-
|Standard || Verifiable || Truth || Truth?
|'''Standard||[[wp:Wikipedia:Verifiability|Verifiable]]||Truth||Truth?
|-
|-
|Notability || Non-Notable excluded || inclusive || inclusive
|'''Notability||[[wp:Wikipedia:Notability|non-notable excluded]]||inclusive||inclusive
|-
|-
|Original Research || excluded || invited || OK
|'''Original Research||[[wp:Wikipedia:No original research|excluded]]||invited||OK
|-
|-
|Self-commentary || COI discouraged || permitted || ???
|'''Self-commentary||[[wp:Wikipedia:Conflict of interest|COI discouraged]]||permitted||???
|-
|-
|Offensive (sexual) || permitted || (unresolved) || No censorship
|'''Offensive material<br>(sexual, violence, profanity)||[[wp:Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not censored|permitted]]||(unresolved)||No censorship
|-
|-
|Boldness || Be Bold || Be Bold, but.. || Be Bold
|'''Boldness||[[wp:Wikipedia:Be bold|Be Bold]]||Be Bold, but..||Be Bold
|-
|-
|Rules || Ignore the rules || Please read the rules || ??
|'''Rules||[[wp:Wikipedia:Ignore all rules|Ignore the rules]]||Please read the rules||??
|-
|-
|Software used || MediaWiki || GetWiki || MediaWiki
|'''[[:Category:Wiki Engine|Software used]]||[[:Category:MediaWiki|MediaWiki]]||[[:Category:GetWiki|GetWiki]]||[[:Category:MediaWiki|MediaWiki]]
|-
|-
|Archived by 3rd party? || Many unofficial mirrors || ?? || No
|'''[[:Category:Wiki Backups|Archived by 3rd party]]||Many unofficial mirrors||??||No
|-
|-
|database download published online || Yes || ?? || No
|'''database download published online||Yes||??||No
|}
|}


Notes: Statistics as of 29jan07.  If they are more than 30 days out of date, please update them.
Notes: Statistics as of 29jan07.  If they are more than 30 days out of date, please update them.


Anonymous - [[OpenEdit]] - Anyone can edit content, without registration <br>
Anonymous — [[:Category:OpenEdit|OpenEdit]] – anyone can edit content, without registration<br>
Registered only - [[LoginToEdit]] - Registration required <br>
Registered only — [[:Category:LoginToEdit|LoginToEdit]] – registration required<br>
GFDL - GNU Free Documentation License[http://www.fsf.org/licensing/licenses/fdl.html] <br>
GFDL — [[GNU Free Documentation License]] – http://www.fsf.org/licensing/licenses/fdl.html<br>
NPOV - Neutral point of view[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Npov] <br>
NPOV — [[wp:Npov|Neutral point of view]]<br>
SPOV - Sympathetic point of view[http://www.wikinfo.org/wiki.php?title=SPOV] <br>
SPOV — Sympathetic point of view – http://www.wikinfo.org/wiki.php?title=SPOV<br>
COI - Conflict of interest[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Conflict_of_interest] <br>
COI — [[wp:Wikipedia:Conflict of interest|Conflict of interest]]<br>


http://en.wikipedia.org/ ...
http://en.wikipedia.org/ ...
Line 57: Line 59:
http://www.wikiknowledge.net/wiki/
http://www.wikiknowledge.net/wiki/


other:
;other:
http://opencycle.vacommunity.net/ 61 pages
*http://opencycle.vacommunity.net/ 61 pages


future questions:
;future questions:
Archived by archive.org?
*Archived by archive.org?


Additional resources:
;Additional resources:
http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_wikis ...
*http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_wikis ...
http://www.wikiindex.org/Wiki_Index
*http://www.wikiindex.org/WikiIndex


<!-- The author/contributor puts this material in the Public Domain.
<!-- The author/contributor puts this material in the Public Domain.
Please grow this seed by adding/improving, nurturing the spirit. -->
Please grow this seed by adding/improving, nurturing the spirit. -->
[[Category:Browse]]
[[Category:Article templates]]

Revision as of 12:22, 9 January 2012

This article needs updating.

Comparison table of policies and other interesting attributes of general-reference wikis in English (with over 1,000 articles).

Wikipedia WikInfo WikiKnowledge
Size (articles) >3,842,000 35,923
(but mostly imported
and little modified)		 1,812
traffic / SearchEngine ranking
Google PageRank 9/10 0/10 0/10
Average # edits per day ~300,000 ~50 ~10
Admins / Registered users >1,500 / >16,000,000 26 / 1,879 7 / 100
Who can edit Anonymous Registered only Anonymous
License GFDL CC - Creative Commons PD - Public Domain
Scope general-reference general-reference-plus general-reference-plus
Point of view (POV) NPOV SPOV NPOV
Standard Verifiable Truth Truth?
Notability non-notable excluded inclusive inclusive
Original Research excluded invited OK
Self-commentary COI discouraged permitted ???
Offensive material
(sexual, violence, profanity)		 permitted (unresolved) No censorship
Boldness Be Bold Be Bold, but.. Be Bold
Rules Ignore the rules Please read the rules ??
Software used MediaWiki GetWiki MediaWiki
Archived by 3rd party Many unofficial mirrors ?? No
database download published online Yes ?? No

Notes: Statistics as of 29jan07. If they are more than 30 days out of date, please update them.

Anonymous — OpenEdit – anyone can edit content, without registration
Registered only — LoginToEdit – registration required
GFDL — GNU Free Documentation License – http://www.fsf.org/licensing/licenses/fdl.html
NPOV — Neutral point of view
SPOV — Sympathetic point of view – http://www.wikinfo.org/wiki.php?title=SPOV
COI — Conflict of interest

http://en.wikipedia.org/ ... http://www.wikinfo.org/ ... http://www.wikiknowledge.net/wiki/

other
future questions
  • Archived by archive.org?
Additional resources
Retrieved from "https://wikiindex.org/index.php?title=Template:Wikipedia_/_Wikinfo_/_Wikia_/_WikiKnowledge_—_comparison_table&oldid=92113"