Template:Wikipedia / Wikinfo / Wikia / WikiKnowledge — comparison table: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Hoof Hearted (talk | contribs) (update with stats - Wikipedia stuff updated - the other two need doing) |
Hoof Hearted (talk | contribs) (added Wikia) |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
Comparison table of policies and other interesting attributes of general-reference [[wiki]]s in [[:Category:Wiki English|English]] (with over 1,000 articles). | Comparison table of policies and other interesting attributes of general-reference [[wiki]]s in [[:Category:Wiki English|English]] (with over 1,000 articles). | ||
===Table=== | |||
{|class="wikitable" style="text-align:center" | {|class="wikitable" style="text-align:center" | ||
|- | |- | ||
! !!<big>[[:Category:Wikipedia|Wikipedia]]</big>!!<big>[[WikInfo]]</big>!!<big>[[WikiKnowledge]]</big> | ! !!<big>[[:Category:Wikipedia|Wikipedia]]</big>!!<big>[[WikInfo]]</big>!!<big>[[WikiKnowledge]]</big>!!<big>[[:Category:Wikia|Wikia]]</big> | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''[[:Category:Wiki Size| | |'''[[:Category:Wiki Size|size (# articles)]]||[[wp:Special:Statistics|>3,842,000]]||35,923<br><small>(but mostly imported<br>and little modified)</small>||1,812||[http://www.wikia.com/Special:Search?search=List+of+Wikia >12,000] | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''traffic / SearchEngine ranking|| || || | |'''traffic / SearchEngine ranking||???||???||???||??? | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''Google PageRank||9/10||0/10||0/10 | |'''Google PageRank||9/10||0/10||0/10||?/10 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''[[:Category:Wiki Status| | |'''[[:Category:Wiki Status|average # edits per day]]||~300,000||~50||~10||??? | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''[[sysop| | |'''[[sysop|admins]] / registered users||[[wp:Special:Statistics|>1,500 / >16,000,000]]||26 / 1,879||7 / 100||??? / ???? | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''[[:Category:Wiki Edit Mode| | |'''[[:Category:Wiki Edit Mode|who can edit]]||[[:Category:OpenEdit|anonymous]]||[[:Category:LoginToEdit|registered only]]||[[:Category:OpenEdit|anonymous]]||[[:Category:OpenEdit|anonymous]] | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''[[:Category:Wiki License| | |'''[[:Category:Wiki License|license of content]]||[[GNU Free Documentation License|GFDL]]||[[:Category:Wiki Creative Commons|CC - Creative Commons]] ?||[[:Category:Wiki Public Domain (generic)|PD - Public Domain]]||[[:Category:Wiki Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike|CC-BY-SA]] | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''[[:Category:Wiki Topic| | |'''[[:Category:Wiki Topic|scope]]||[[wp:Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not|general-reference]]||general-reference-plus||general-reference-plus||general-reference-plus | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''[[:Category:PointOfView| | |'''[[:Category:PointOfView|point of view]] (POV)||[[NPOV]]||[[SPOV]]||NPOV||??? | ||
|- | |- | ||
|''' | |'''[[WikiIndex:Verifiable|standard]]||[[wp:Wikipedia:Verifiability|verifiable]]||truth||truth?||??? | ||
|- | |- | ||
|''' | |'''notability||[[wp:Wikipedia:Notability|non-notable excluded]]||inclusive||inclusive||anything goes | ||
|- | |- | ||
|''' | |'''original research (OR)||[[wp:Wikipedia:No original research|excluded]]||invited||OK||??? | ||
|- | |- | ||
|''' | |'''self-commentary||[[wp:Wikipedia:Conflict of interest|COI discouraged]]||permitted||???||??? | ||
|- | |- | ||
|''' | |'''offensive material<br>(sexual, violence, profanity)||[[wp:Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not censored|permitted]]||(unresolved)||no censorship||??? | ||
|- | |- | ||
|''' | |'''boldness||[[wp:Wikipedia:Be bold|Be Bold]]||Be Bold, but..||Be Bold||??? | ||
|- | |- | ||
|''' | |'''rules||[[wp:Wikipedia:Ignore all rules|Ignore the rules]]||Please read the rules||???||??? | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''[[:Category:Wiki Engine| | |'''[[:Category:Wiki Engine|software used]] ('WikiEngine')||[[:Category:MediaWiki|MediaWiki]]||[[:Category:GetWiki|GetWiki]]||[[:Category:MediaWiki|MediaWiki]]||heavily modified [[:Category:MediaWiki|MediaWiki]] | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''[[:Category:Wiki Backups| | |'''[[:Category:Wiki Backups|archived by 3rd party]]||many unofficial mirrors||???||no||internally by Wikia | ||
|- | |- | ||
|'''database download published online|| | |'''database download published online||yes||???||no||from Wikia article 'Statistics' page | ||
|} | |} | ||
:''Statistics as of 29jan07.<!--Wikipedia & Wikia updated Jan 2012--> If they are more than 30 days out of date, please update them. | |||
===Notes=== | |||
Anonymous — [[:Category:OpenEdit|OpenEdit]] – anyone can edit content, without registration<br> | Anonymous — [[:Category:OpenEdit|OpenEdit]] – anyone can edit content, without registration<br> | ||
Registered only — [[:Category:LoginToEdit|LoginToEdit]] – registration required<br> | Registered only — [[:Category:LoginToEdit|LoginToEdit]] – registration required<br> | ||
| Line 55: | Line 57: | ||
COI — [[wp:Wikipedia:Conflict of interest|Conflict of interest]]<br> | COI — [[wp:Wikipedia:Conflict of interest|Conflict of interest]]<br> | ||
http://en.wikipedia.org | http://en.wikipedia.org • | ||
http://www.wikinfo.org | http://www.wikinfo.org • | ||
http://www.wikiknowledge.net/wiki/ | http://www.wikiknowledge.net/wiki • | ||
http://www.wikia.com | |||
;other: | ;other: | ||
*http://opencycle.vacommunity.net | *http://opencycle.vacommunity.net 61 pages | ||
;future questions: | ;future questions: | ||
*Archived by archive.org? | *Archived by http://archive.org ?? | ||
; | ;additional resources: | ||
*http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_wikis ... | *http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_wikis ... | ||
* | *[[WikiIndex]] | ||
<!-- The author/contributor puts this material in the Public Domain. | <!-- The author/contributor puts this material in the Public Domain. | ||
Revision as of 13:09, 19 January 2012
- This article needs updating.
Comparison table of policies and other interesting attributes of general-reference wikis in English (with over 1,000 articles).
Table
| Wikipedia | WikInfo | WikiKnowledge | Wikia | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| size (# articles) | >3,842,000 | 35,923 (but mostly imported and little modified) |
1,812 | >12,000 |
| traffic / SearchEngine ranking | ??? | ??? | ??? | ??? |
| Google PageRank | 9/10 | 0/10 | 0/10 | ?/10 |
| average # edits per day | ~300,000 | ~50 | ~10 | ??? |
| admins / registered users | >1,500 / >16,000,000 | 26 / 1,879 | 7 / 100 | ??? / ???? |
| who can edit | anonymous | registered only | anonymous | anonymous |
| license of content | GFDL | CC - Creative Commons ? | PD - Public Domain | CC-BY-SA |
| scope | general-reference | general-reference-plus | general-reference-plus | general-reference-plus |
| point of view (POV) | NPOV | SPOV | NPOV | ??? |
| standard | verifiable | truth | truth? | ??? |
| notability | non-notable excluded | inclusive | inclusive | anything goes |
| original research (OR) | excluded | invited | OK | ??? |
| self-commentary | COI discouraged | permitted | ??? | ??? |
| offensive material (sexual, violence, profanity) |
permitted | (unresolved) | no censorship | ??? |
| boldness | Be Bold | Be Bold, but.. | Be Bold | ??? |
| rules | Ignore the rules | Please read the rules | ??? | ??? |
| software used ('WikiEngine') | MediaWiki | GetWiki | MediaWiki | heavily modified MediaWiki |
| archived by 3rd party | many unofficial mirrors | ??? | no | internally by Wikia |
| database download published online | yes | ??? | no | from Wikia article 'Statistics' page |
- Statistics as of 29jan07. If they are more than 30 days out of date, please update them.
Notes
Anonymous — OpenEdit – anyone can edit content, without registration
Registered only — LoginToEdit – registration required
GFDL — GNU Free Documentation License – http://www.fsf.org/licensing/licenses/fdl.html
NPOV — Neutral point of view
SPOV — Sympathetic point of view – http://www.wikinfo.org/wiki.php?title=SPOV
COI — Conflict of interest
http://en.wikipedia.org • http://www.wikinfo.org • http://www.wikiknowledge.net/wiki • http://www.wikia.com
- other
- http://opencycle.vacommunity.net 61 pages
- future questions
- Archived by http://archive.org ??
- additional resources