211
edits
Category talk:Wikia: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Review policy related link added to 'Criticism' section
(Reply to 'Criticism') |
(Review policy related link added to 'Criticism' section) |
||
| Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
:Hmm. Is WikiIndex here to '''list''' wikis or to '''review''' them? If information about Wikia's flaws is put up (and I'm not necessarily saying it shouldn't) does that mean that problems with other wiki farms should be listed? Does that mean that problems with all wikis should be listed? Is criticism actually useful? Should WikiIndex have a "no original criticism" rule, that requires criticism to be citated back to an external source? | :Hmm. Is WikiIndex here to '''list''' wikis or to '''review''' them? If information about Wikia's flaws is put up (and I'm not necessarily saying it shouldn't) does that mean that problems with other wiki farms should be listed? Does that mean that problems with all wikis should be listed? Is criticism actually useful? Should WikiIndex have a "no original criticism" rule, that requires criticism to be citated back to an external source? | ||
:BTW: You might be interested to know that a user called CatherineMunro edited this page. There is a CatherineMunro over at Wikia. I personally find her very helpful, and (if this CatherineMunro is the Wikia one) she doesn't seem to have removed any criticism, but it has been snipped a bit. (Mostly the cruft about Wikia being like "New Coke" - which is meaningless to non-Americans anyway - has been cut.) [[User:David Shepheard|David Shepheard]] 21:14, 23 April 2009 (EDT) | :BTW: You might be interested to know that a user called CatherineMunro edited this page. There is a CatherineMunro over at Wikia. I personally find her very helpful, and (if this CatherineMunro is the Wikia one) she doesn't seem to have removed any criticism, but it has been snipped a bit. (Mostly the cruft about Wikia being like "New Coke" - which is meaningless to non-Americans anyway - has been cut.) [[User:David Shepheard|David Shepheard]] 21:14, 23 April 2009 (EDT) | ||
::A discussion about the WikiIndex policy on reviews of wikis (or wikifarms like Wikia) has now started. See: [[WikiIndex_talk:Community_talk#Site_reviews]] if you want to be involved in this. [[User:David Shepheard|David Shepheard]] 07:14, 9 May 2009 (EDT) | |||
== WikiNode deleted == | == WikiNode deleted == | ||